Brian Tilaro's MS Blog
Ask questions about the Procedure, talk about experiences, whatever...
Introduction
photo

Greetings to all,



I deeply apologize for the delay in updating my progress after the procedure ended last July 27, 2007.
Leaving Chicago on August 02, 2007 to fly home to San Diego was very difficult as I was extremely weak. I
would tire very easily and had to stop to rest many times. Thank God my wife, Charo was there to assist
me. The flight itself was uncomfortable in so many different ways. But it was good to get home again. Here
is an account of my experiences from August 01, 2007 to October 27, 2007.



The nausea from the chemo had passed and I could eat, just not normal quantities of food. When I
weighed myself at home I found that I had lost 30 pounds during the procedure. I was not sleeping well,
awakening often at night. Even minor physical exertion, like walking upstairs, caused me to sweat heavily.
My legs and arm had lost considerable muscle mass. As my immune system was that of a newborn baby,
I was to avoid crowded places, animals, and all kids. I could see friends a couple at a time. I get blood
drawn every week or two to ensure my counts are getting back to normal. So far, so good. Still no hair,
though. I think I'll just keep it like this.



A few days after I got home, my old MS flare-ups started. I was advised by the Immunologist that this would
likely occur as my body just went through a great deal of stress from the procedure. (And those of you with
MS know that it doesn't take much stress to trigger a relapse.). This time, however, all of the symptoms
from past relapses occurred at the same time (with the exception of Optic Neuritis, that did not recur). The
symptoms were spasms and pain in all extremities as well as the trunk of my body to the neck, loss of
sense of balance, and severe lower back pain, ringing and buzzing in both ears, and urinary problems.
Stiffness in the leg muscles and severe fatigue. The most debilitating of the flare-ups were bouts of deep
depression. If you've had real depression, you know what I'm saying. But my wife and mother-in-law made
me as comfortable as they could and took care of my daily needs.



The doctor told me I would improve in overall health in 7-10 weeks to the point where I should be more
functional (strength returns, MS flare-ups would recede, etc. He explained it to me like this: "What you went
through physically with the MS and this procedure gave me something similar to Post-traumatic Stress
Syndrome. He may have been right in my case.



August was the bad month. But in September I started getting my strength back. The MS flare-ups were
still there, but they moved more into the background, if you know what I mean. The heat in September didn't
help as they tended to make the fatigue stronger in the heat of the day. But overall, my health improved
steadily in September. I wish I could show you all a graph as the improvements were not in a straight line.  
They came and went in cycles. Some days would be good days and some days would be bad days. Some
days the flare-up cycle were strong. Some days I felt like my old self again.



By the end of September, I stubbornly carried boxes and moved furniture. That one weekend set me back
into the bad cycle and it lasted for weeks, into October. I was heavily scolded by my wife and doctor to not
do anything like that for at least a year.



I have started work again as an auto claims adjuster for the same company I worked before. They were
gracious and flexible to my needs. State Disability (which I was on from May through September) payments
do not pay a living wage. But I was glad SDI was there, It was better than nothing, Going back to work is
another transition that was a bit difficult, but I think it was good for my mind to be focused on something
else.



Now for the Prognosis that everyone was waiting for:



Has the procedure shown any benefit yet?

Do I expect to be cured of MS completely from this procedure?



Since it's barely been three months since the procedure, I've not seen any definitive improvement. But the
timeline for true benefits to appear is 12-18 months. So I have a ways to go before I know if current
flare-ups disappear and no new lesions appear.



You see, that was the rationale to do this procedure. My EDSS Score was 2.5. I was a good candidate. I
knew there was a possibility that lesions already established might heal; and they might not. Depending
on the amount of damage done to the nerve. However, my true motivation for doing this procedure was the
chemo I went through destroyed my immune system, thus destroying the malfunctioned immune memory
that was attacking my central nervous system. This all means that the chances are very good (over 80%)
that there will be no further MS attacks. I can live with the disabilities I already have. I do not want to add to
them.



MS being a progressive disease, the prognosis will always be toward further disability and loss of quality
of life. I did this procedure because it was my only hope to be able to provide a quality life for my family.
Otherwise, my wife could look forward to years of my progressive physical deterioration. I would not do that
to my wife if there was any way to stop it.



Until then, God Bless.



Brian Tilaro


2007-11-11 00:35:18 GMT
Comments (16 total)
Author:Anonymous
Hi Brian

I look forward to your updates and pray for you everday.
2007-11-20 19:56:32 GMT
Author:Anonymous
Brian,

First of all I want to say I hope you are doing better each and everyday. I think about you and pray for you all the time.

Your site is full of information that has spared me from doing my own research.

Re: Other possible institutions that may be doing similar procedures, but not
listed on ClinicalTrials.gov. I will add to the list as I can find and verify them.

You listed two of them being in Colorado but not confirmed. I am moving to Colorado after the next of the year. Just curious how you heard or why you think these locations will offer SCT?

If that's the case, that would really be helpful as far as my family is concerned. No flying out of state etc.. to see a physican and to receive treamtment.

I hope by the time I deliver I am elig for treatment. Right now my lefs feel like lead and I can hardly walk. Waiting for get IVIG.. if it doesnt help I am afraid I might have slipped into SPMS because the steroids didnt get me out of this attack either.

take care and keep healing.


--Kat
2007-12-07 21:36:09 GMT
Author:Anonymous
Kat,

Thanks for the kind words. I am now showing some real signs of improvement. More strength, better walking, no slurring speech, etc. Some of the symptoms are still there. I still have bad periods. But the good periods are lasting longer and the bad periods are of a much shorter duration. Last bad one lasted only three days.

I can now say that there has been improvement.

With regard to the University of Colorado, I did not find enough information on their procedures involving autologous stem cells for MS. But they have a major cancer research center there, so that is probably what they're using it for. That's why I emphasized "probably" on my website. I could not be certain.

You may want to call the University and ask to speak to someone in Neurology or Immunology about possible HSCT for MS. You'll probably get passed from one person to another, but you'll eventually get to the person who can answwer your question. It just takes tenacity.

I'm glad the information on my site could help you. That is why I put it there. It took me months to drill down to the critical information. I want others to avoid doing that as much as possible. No sense in reinventing the wheel.

My wife got me through some really bad times this last year. Your husband can help you a great deal during this time. Even if it is just with emotional support and being there. I cannot emphasize that enough.

You are in my prayers daily.

Brian
2007-12-08 05:42:10 GMT
Author:Anonymous
Brain I read your symptom history blog. I just had a few questions.

Did your symptoms keep getting worse?

Did you try steroids and did they help?

Ever experience weakness?

I guess i am trying to figure out how they determine when we turn to SPMS vs RRMS. I do know to guidelines for RRMS, but they seem to cross over sometimes.

I plan on going to for SCT, but as I mentioned before I am fearful I might have slipped to SPMS since my symptoms are increasing as my disability at a rapid rate. Steroids didnt work and the IVIG helped very little if at all.

I am pretty nervous and right now they cant tell me what I am.
--Kat
2007-12-12 21:29:08 GMT
Author:Anonymous
Kat,

One thing that I noticed about relapses is that they can last anywhere from 6-8 months from start to remittance. Last year at this time I was in very bad shape. I was barely able to walk, no balance, spasms throughout my entire body, intense tightening of major muscle groups that was very painful, along with deep depression. I also experienced intense fatigue and muscle weakness, as well as urinary retention problems. All this lasted from September of 2006 to March of 2007, when the majority of the symptoms started to fade away.

It was during this time that I did most of my research into MS and possible effective treatments. That's how I found the HSCT. As you know, I underwent the procedure last summer.

What I'm getting at here is that different relapses can, and do, overlap each other. It feels like you're progressing rapidly. But I've found that is usually not the case. RRMS has differing degrees of severity and can take many months to remit. But what characterizes SPMS from RRMS is that, in SPMS the relapses do not go away and each new relapse builds upon the last toward further disability. I'm not sure of your situation or how long you've had these symptoms, but if it has only just recently (with last year or two) been really bad, then it is probably not SPMS. SPMS takes time to develop. More than just a couple of years. About half of the people with RRMS eventually reach SPMS, regardless of the drugs they take. You being pregnant is stressful on the body, which can easily trigger existing relapses.

Regarding your second question: I did take IV corticosteroids (Solumedrol) twice. In September of 2006 and in November of 2006. They helped a little, but not very much in my opinion. It gives you bad insominia, too.

I was never given IVIG as an option. But I had a really crappy neurologist, one who was way too overworked that did not have any time to see me when I was in really bad shape. I'd been to the ER more than once last year.

Bottom line is that Relapses can take months to resolve. Sometime these relapses overlap each other, making life feel like torture. RRMS can be that way at times, I'm told. But that is generally not the primary indicator of SPMS.

There is no real dividing line between RRMS and SPMS that can be quantified. I don't think you'll find a neurologist that will say definitively that you are in SPMS. As I said, the nature of MS is toward progression, always. But it is different with each person, so trying to put a diagnostic label like SPMS is difficult.

There are no real guidelines for MS. No Line Graph that you can point to and say, "Here is where I am in the MS progression.". What it takes is for a neurologist to evaluate your progression over long periods of time (years) so that he/she can track the course of your disease. Only then, I think, can you get the diagnosis of SPMS or PPMS.

I am so sorry for being so long-winded. But I get the impression that this is something that is weighing heavily on your mind.

All I can say is, "Time and Patience". Time to have your baby, time to get your strength back from birth. Time to go through the SCT procedure. Months to recover from the chemo. and even more months (about 18 months) after the procedure before any real lasting benefits are achieved. And unfortunately, you have to have the patience to go though all of that. There is a definite sequence of events between all those things listed.

So try not to worry about SPMS. Concentrate on making it through the first step that will get you to the time of SCT procedure.

This is my essay. I am sorry it is so long. Once I get started, it's hard to stop.

Sincerely,

Brian
--Brian
<http://www.allyoumed.com>
2007-12-16 03:58:29 GMT
Author:Anonymous
Just wanted to wish you a Merry Christmas!!

Wishing you great health for 2008.
2007-12-24 18:16:48 GMT
Author:Anonymous
Brian, I'm sure you know this from the number of emails I send you, but I wanted to let you know that I think of you often and that I hope for your tood health.
--Tim Ratcliffe
2008-01-30 20:34:43 GMT
Author:Anonymous
Tim,

Thanks. I enjoy our emaails, and agree with most of them.

Brian
2008-01-31 03:55:17 GMT
Author:Anonymous
Tim,

Thanks. I enjoy our emaails, and agree with most of them.

Brian
2008-01-31 03:56:21 GMT
Author:Anonymous
Hi Brian.

I just wanted to let you know I am having my csection feb 15th. FINALLY can get this over with and heal and I talk to my neuro march 6th.

I do not know if I will be considered for the SCT here in Dallas. I have discussed it with my neuro and they kept pushing tysabri on me. I asked if I would be considered for SCT, they wouldn't give me an answer. So lets hope.

My flair has been unkind to me and last many months now, so I am not sure of I couild call it a flair anymore. Legs are so stiff, weak and numb, dizziness is fun too. :(

Whatever happens I just wanted to thank you for at least letting me know there are other treatments I can pursue and give me some hope.

I am anxious to find out what your MRI results are. Unless I missed them posted somewhere.

I hope you are doing well and symptoms improving.

God Bless
2008-02-08 19:49:46 GMT
Author:Anonymous
Sorry I haven't posted in a while, what with prepartion for the trip to Chicago and all. I also got the bad case of the flu, which put me out of commission for a while. I'm slowly gtetting better.

I am waiting for the evaluation reports before I post anything to the website. I want to make sure that it is clear that the results are from a medical doctor and not my subjective opinion.

Congratulations on the birth of your new child. I pray that you recover quickly and can get accepted into the program in Dallas.

God bless,

Brian
2008-02-23 20:06:47 GMT
Author:Anonymous
I had a baby girl on feb 15th. Thankfully my symtpoms went away about a week after giving birth.

I have since been contacted by a doctor at John Hopkins, they do a procedure similar to what you had.. 4-5 days of chemo but instead of stem cells they use a med called revimmune. They said it has the same success rate as the SCT but with a lower farality rate. They also decided to put thier patients on copaxone after treatment to help retrain the immune system.

They said there is no way with either procedure that they can erase the bad cells causing us problems. they said even with the washing etc... it only takes one of two to get by. They feel we need meds for life inspite of treatments.

I fo in march 6th to talk to my neuro about my options, but I will have tests run and have them sent off to john hopkins and also reconsider the SCT here in Dallas.

It is scary but I am ready.
2008-03-01 18:08:35 GMT
Author:Anonymous
Kat,

Great news. Check out my site. There is finaly evidence from my MRI's and EDss scores that the HSCT procedure I underwent at Northwestern was succesful. I am in complete remission and my lesions are slowly healing. My strength has improved as well.

I still have my old symptoms, but they are becoming less debilitating and are of short duration (hours). I am now at a point where my quality of life is almost back to what it was before.

I still have a long way to go in the recovery process. But this has been a miracle for me; especially compared to the way I felt 12 months ago.

Just wanted you to know.

God bless,

Brian
2008-04-01 04:03:22 GMT
Author:Anonymous
Hi Brian-

I would first like to thank you for being so diligent in putting up this site and sharing your experiences with us. Your experiences will help many and your honesty and faith are very refreshing and encouraging.

I am currently being considered and tested for this procedure.

A bit of my background: 1st attack 2002, dx'd w/RRMS 2003, used Copaxone for 2 years, 2005 stopped COP and went Naturopathic for 2 1/2 years, 2008 dx'd SPMS due to rapid advancement of physical disability, chemo is recommended - if I am a candidate, I will most likely undergo this treatment in December. I grew up with 7 siblings, 6 sisters, 1 bro. I had 1 sister with MS, dx'd at age 22 - she died 4 years ago at age 47 (this is the same age that I am now). No one else from my fam has this disease.

I fear that if I don't have the chemo, I will not live to see age 50. While I truly hate pharmaceuticals, I just don't feel that I have the luxury of time - in 2 1/2 years I have gone from an active, briskly walking individual, to a wheelchair-using cripple. Although I can still walk, I am very unsteady and my fatigue level is off the charts, some days it is all I can do just to get myself downstairs into the family room to just veg on a recliner for the day, then climb the mountain of stairs back to my bed at nite.

I live with my devoted husband and three teens, girls age 18 & 16, and my son who is 13. My granddaughter also lives with us, she is 10 months and the light of my life.

My belief is that I will either be gone from the MS or from trying to rid myself of it. I believe that my life is in God's hands, by His hands only will His plan for me be carried out.

I do have a few questions for you if you're up to them.

God's blessings to you and your Family-

binnie


--Binnie
2008-09-19 21:41:44 GMT
Author:Anonymous
Thank God is all I can say. I had the procedure done many years ago myself at the same place as you. It gave me 5 years of fantastic quality of life. Having just come out of a pretty big, scary flare-up, I can tell you what you already know. God is the way before, during, and after modern medicine has anything for anyone to offer. Prayer really does change things. I am so thankful to God. I am enjoying every day, every minute, every second of every day now that I am living, breathing, and walking..able to think for myself and do for myself and others. Enjoying excellent health now thanks to God. If you should happen to find yourself in another flare-up of any kind, (and I pray that you won't), have faith that this procedure that you and I did, just may very well have minimized the affects that we would have endured had we not had this procedure done in the first place. Above all..your faith in God can work miracles. I've seen way to much to believe anything else. So many thanks go to your wife for being there for you, too. To the caretakers out there reading this...thank you so very much. May the good lord bless you and keep you always..and you will remain in my prayers.
--Rhonda G
2009-05-15 10:25:41 GMT
Author:Anonymous
Rhonda,

Thank you so much for your words. I am doing much better. It's been a slow improvement since the procedure. But that is what Dr. Burt said would happen. I pray the improvements continue.

I am happy to hear from another person out there who has gone thru this procedure as well.

God bless,

Brian
--Brian Tilaro
<http://www.allyoumed.com>
2009-05-19 20:07:26 GMT
Add to My Yahoo! RSS